Life is wonderful, isn’t it? Well, at least mine is at the moment. My apartment is filled with light and has a surprisingly good location, with a really nice landlord and a well-working heating system. Against all odds my health is steady due to some intense medication and like this wasn’t enough already, things in both my job and private life are going really well right now.
Everything seems to be alright somehow – a feeling I’m not really used to as there is always something going wrong. Except right now.
And therefore I could be seen running through this world lately with a big and maybe even extremely stupid smile on my face.
I’m having fun in life.
Oops, no…sorry…I’m a Christian. And as such I don’t have fun, but am being joyful. At least, that’s what I’ve been told.
And “being joyful” here is commonly defined as being in a good mood and ready for joking all the time. All the time. 24-7-52. Or in other words: all the time.
Oh yeah, we Christians are a joyous crowd…
Anyone but me. And maybe you aren’t either.
Between you and me and the gatepost: my nature isn’t really what you’d call a sunny disposition. I ponder a lot, see the world a bit more pessimistic or at least more questioning than most others, worry more about things than I should and have spent most of my life on the rather seamy side of life. I know from personal experience that life isn’t always fun (oops, sorry…joyous) and can even hurt from time to time. There have been more days than one in my life when I was rather Chief Thundercloud than Little Miss Sunshine – and I am well aware that there will be more days like that. Even now, as everything seems to be going my way, there is this little thundercloud floating over my head and casting a almost invisible shadow onto my soul. I know life isn’t pink and fluffy.
And somehow it really feels awesomely good sometimes to cut myself off the rest of the world and to wallow in world weariness, melancholy and self-pity, supported by some nice depressive music coming out of my stereo.
That’s what I think.
Seriously.
And this is an attitude that is actually able to spoil the joy for some of my fellow Christians.
Because there aren’t few of them who believe that my current and certainly temporary emotional high is the actual every-day mood for “real” Christians. In other words: “real” Christians are always cheerful, never depressed and never experience doubts, worries or fears, as they always “hand things over to the Lord” easily and smoothly “walk in the joy of the Lord”.
I really don’t want to sound cynical or judge people who think like that. But I still want to challenge their viewpoint. We usually forget way too fast that there are people around us whose feelings are completely different from ours. Accordingly, there aren’t only sanguine Christians but also those of us who didn’t get their rose-colored sunglasses.
Due to several reasons dealing with people with this pushy sunshine-attitude is quite difficult for me. And by the way: I am not the only one. I know from some of my friends who are also rather melancholic that they find reacting to this opinion appropriately quite difficult too. Maybe you are also one of us.
In my opinion this attitude that Christians must always be in a good mood, cracking jokes and grinning like a Cheshire cat is nonsense. To be more clear about it: I consider this a wrong and harmful theology which both keeps people from exploiting their whole potential and can even make people ill!
This may not be intentional but that doesn’t make things less severe.
Yes, we are called to hand our worries over to God (1Peter 5:7), to come to Jesus with our burdens (Matthew 11:28) and to watch our lives with confidence (e.g. 2Corinthians 3:12). And we have a reason for that! The almighty Lord and Creator of the universe has shown Himself in his Son Jesus Christ and has saved and freed us from our sins by Jesus’ death on the cross and His resurrection.
We are free.
I am free.
Free from all the deficits of my character, all the things I failed at in my past (and will fail at in my future), I am wanted and love and may know my life safely cradled in the hands of my gracious Lord.
How awesome is that?!
Seriously….there’s nothing more I could long for.
But nevertheless I must also face reality in me and around me – all the illness; all my deficits that are so evident so often – and those of the people around me; all the suffering in my close environment, hopelessness etc. Sorry, but when I think about how many people close to me will be lost, I loose my smile. And when I bring to my mind how many of my (former and current) students have had to suffer from whatever kind of misuse or are still suffering from it, my heart is breaking. How am I supposed to be joyous then? When I’m (once again) sitting in front of a student who has just told me that she’s been threatened with being belted again if she brings home another D (as happened some years ago), what am I supposed to do as a joyous Christian? Tell her with a holy smile that “God works all things for the good for those who follow him”?! Of course this verse is true and of course I’ve been receiving comfort from it for years (after my father’s death and my decision to follow Jesus Romans8:28 was the first Bible verse I ever memorized). But telling this to somebody in a situation like that would be misanthropic. And it would dispose me from any right to give advice and support to this person. Honestly, if anybody had dared to beat verses like that around my head back then in my desperate situation, I would have beaten back with other things…
Going through this life with this permanent joyous smile on our face and shielding us emotionally from all the negative emotions and sad realities in this world while we’re surrounded by pain and misery would be scornful and therefore not according to God’s will. We are supposed to rejoice with those who rejoice and mourn with those who mourn (Romans 12:15)!
And with regards to ourselves it is important in my opinion that we face up to our own emotional worlds and allow negative emotions. Repression has never gotten anybody anywhere. And I know from personal experience how destroying it is to smile, crack jokes and be joyous on the outside, while you’re fading away underneath the exterior because of pain and sadness. And how try to distract yourself from this pain with all kinds of substitute actions then in order to lead yourself to believe that everything is fine. This is self-parody and only leads to some really bizarre behavior. Not only among Christians, but also among Non-Christians…
We are called to be light and salt for this world (Matthew 5:13+14). But we can only be so by being authentic. And we can only be authentic by being honest with ourselves. How do we expect to be light and set an example how to master life with all its highs and lows with the help of God when people notice straight away that we’re only presenting a religious show and are actually nothing but fake when it comes to our own feelings?! Believe me, people won’t need much time to realize. You don’t really need much psychological knowledge for that – sooner or later we’ll be busted. How embarrassing…
We don’t really help anybody by pretending that we’re always doing fine and are always flying on cloud number nine, buzzing as toddlers in a wading pool. It is rather the other way round. Reliance on God, comfort in the Holy Spirit, renewal, encouragement etc are wonderful elements of a sounds and vivid relationship with God. How do we want to set an example in experiencing these things without allowing negative emotions in our lives? That won’t work.
We must be willing to walk through valleys if we want to show the people around us what an awesome mountain guide we have in Jesus.
And we must allow negative emotions to develop our personalities. Personality development is always connected with pain. Old Sigmund Freud once said that development always comes along with emotional agitation or trauma. Forgive me for invoking an un-Christian guy like Freud, but I still stick to the motto “eat the meat, spit out the bones”. Old Freud may have lots of obvious bones in his theories but also lots of recommendable meat… In my opinion he is right with his statement about emotional agitation and I think this statement is even right from a Christian perspective:
Whenever we ask God to form our characters in order to make us more similar to Himself, we should adjust ourselves to emotional pain. For we can only get better when we get rid of the things in us that are in need of improvement. And in order to be able to get rid of those things we must notice them. And in order to notice them, God must make us aware of them. I have experienced my deepest troughs after having asked God to improve my character. And I always came out of them as a better, stronger me, much more deeply rooted in faith as ever before and as I ever would have thought to hope for (The requests “Lord, teach me humbleness” and “Lord, transform me into a person of your heart” are really dangerous. I can only encourage you to tell them to Him again and again. You’ll be surprised. And you’ll survive the pain!).
By pretending that everything was alright and not facing my negative emotions or unpleasant character traits inside of me, but surpressing them instead and busily polishing my halo, I chuck away the chance of getting to know God on a much deeper level and of being transformed more into His image. Do you want that? I don’t. If I get closer to my Lord and get transformed into a better version of mine by it, I’ll happily accept that “little” pain.
We can also find some quite demonstrative examples for melancholics in the Bible. Some of the men and women of God were real hardcore-emos. Jeremiah, for example, Noomi, Elija and also Thomas were quite straight forward there… distrustful (John 20:25), bitter (Ruth 1:20), pessimistic (John 11:16) or suicidal (Jeremiah 20:14-18; 1Kings 19:4) but still men and women God used to make history with – because they didn’t stick to their pain but sooner or later arrived at a point of their lives when they handed themselves, their lives, their pain, un-will to live and doubts over to God.
And that’s an aspect where my sunshine-friends are right: sooner or later I must give my pain and everything pressing me down to God. When I do this is up to me.
And I must keep in mind that letting go is a process – that may take months or even years. And that I might need professional support for. That’s alright.
Inner healing is reality.
But it’s also a process.
Processes need time. And we have all the time in the world.
So don’t let anybody tell you that your sadness, despair or brokenness was a sign for spiritual immaturity or that you weren’t allowed to feel or undergo your negative emotions. For this is not the case.
I am convinced that I will always be a little melancholic. Sooner or later I will be in that place again when this little thundercloud appears over my head and the harmonies in life transpose from C major to D minor. And I’m fine with that. No good composition on this planet only contains major harmonies and a field that is never rained on will never fructify.
And that’s what this is all about, right? Fructifying and being an euphony to this disharmonic world.
Does life hurt sometimes? Yes.
Am I sometimes seriously fed up with everything and complain to God about the dirt I’m stuck in (and that I’ve probably brought myself into)? Of course.
Am I having fun in life? Ooooh yeah!
Joy as well. But that won’t go any further. I count on you…
I am very thankful for all the good things God is giving me. And I am thankful just as much that He is working on and in me in order to improve my life even more – and that He is giving me all the time in our mutual times of growth and upgrade phases I need to wallow in self-pity or to growl at Him until I remember what really matters.
And that’s Jesus.
He is my sunshine, my only sunshine. He makes me happy, when skies are grey.
God bless you!